Benjamin Burnley vs. EA: A Lesson in Authenticity Gone Awry

In partnership with

You know you’ve hit a snag in influencer marketing when your campaign ends up on Instagram—but for all the wrong reasons.

Enter Benjamin Burnley, the outspoken lead singer of Breaking Benjamin, who famously shattered EA’s hopes (and a Star Wars Battlefront disc) in one Instagram post.

This fiasco is a masterclass in what happens when influencer marketing prioritizes optics over authenticity—and how that can backfire spectacularly.

The Broken Deal

In 2015, EA approached Burnley to promote Star Wars Battlefront on his social channels. But there was one small problem: Burnley hated the game. And he didn’t hold back.

Instead of cashing the check, Burnley took to Instagram, posting a photo of a cracked Battlefront disc with the caption:

They wanted to pay me to post that I like this piece of sh*t game. They can shove it up their as*. This game su*ks.

The post went viral, and so did the backlash against EA. Suddenly, what was supposed to be a slick influencer collaboration turned into a PR nightmare.

Where EA Went Wrong

1. Skipping the Connection Test

   Burnley was a strange choice for a Star Wars game campaign. His persona—edgy, raw, and brutally honest—was at odds with EA’s polished, corporate vibe. A quick look at his social media would’ve revealed he wasn’t the type to sugarcoat his opinions.

2. Forcing Enthusiasm

   Authenticity is the currency of influencer marketing. Fans can tell when someone’s heart isn’t in it. EA’s attempt to turn Burnley into a brand ambassador without ensuring he genuinely liked the product led to the very outcome they were trying to avoid.

3. Underestimating Transparency

   Burnley’s unapologetic honesty resonated with his fans, even as it torpedoed EA’s campaign. His bluntness served as a stark reminder: Influencers can make or break your brand, especially when they have a fiercely loyal audience.

Lessons from the Fallout

1. Know Your Influencer: Influencers aren’t just walking billboards. Their personality, values, and audience must align with your brand.

2. Prioritize Authenticity: Paid promotions only work when there’s genuine enthusiasm for the product. Fans value honesty over polished scripts.

3. Vet Your Strategy: A big name doesn’t always mean big results. Dig deeper to ensure the partnership makes sense beyond surface-level reach.

Why It Still Matters

The Burnley x EA saga underscores the importance of trust and authenticity in today’s marketing landscape. Audiences crave realness, and when brands miss the mark, the internet is quick to call them out.

In a world dominated by influencer collaborations, this debacle remains a cautionary tale of what happens when brands choose reach over resonance.

How Phyllo’s Brand Safety Can Help

EA’s misstep with Benjamin Burnley highlights a critical gap in the influencer marketing process—vetting partnerships for alignment and authenticity. Here’s where Phyllo's Brand Safety solution comes in:

1. Deep Social Media Analysis: With Phyllo, brands can access an influencer's entire social media history, analyzing their tone, values, and past interactions to ensure a perfect match.

2. Audience Insights: Phyllo provides data on an influencer's audience demographics, interests, and engagement patterns, helping brands align their campaigns with the right target market.

3. Real-Time Monitoring: Phyllo offers real-time insights into an influencer’s activity during a campaign, ensuring no surprises or PR crises.

4. Reputation Scoring: Our tools help evaluate an influencer’s alignment with brand values and highlight potential red flags before a partnership begins.

Had EA leveraged a tool like Phyllo, they could have identified Burnley’s misalignment with their brand early, avoiding the costly fallout and preserving their reputation. Learn more here.

Wrap-Up

EA’s influencer misstep with Benjamin Burnley may have ended in disaster, but it’s a goldmine of insights for marketers. Authenticity isn’t optional—it’s essential.

So, what’s your takeaway? Are you investing in genuine partnerships, or are you still chasing the wrong kind of hype?

Stay real, stay relevant, and don’t forget to play smart.

Cheers,

Shubham

Writers, don’t let your work disappear!

Imagine losing years of articles because a site shut down. What would you do if all your work samples disappeared?

With Authory, that’s a nightmare you’ll never have to face. Authory automatically creates a portfolio that backs up everything you’ve ever written and will write, so your work is always safe.

That’s right: Authory finds and backs up all your past work and saves every new piece you publish, wherever they appear.

Join thousands of writers who already trust Authory to protect their work and never lose a piece again.

Get your free portfolio today